Any game that isn't a FPS worth getting? With good replay value?

Try Fallout 3 or Fallout New Vegas. They're both still FPS, BUT they're offline games. They keep you busy for +200 hours (takes longer for 1-2 years if you have a job and life) with the huge storyline, quests, character interaction, etc. They're so fun! You can be anyone you want to be and do anything you want to do it. It has moral choices and you can kill anyone and go anywhere. There's a lot of freedom in it.